Mental Health System and Remand Prisoners

With the news today that an inmate had escaped from the supposedly secure Brentwood unit at Glenside Hospital came the revelation that he was apparently on remand for Assault.

Assuming that "on remand," in the context of that news article, means "remanded in custody" then serious questions need to be asked about why prison inmates are being held in institutions other than prisons. The Correctional Services Act provides that prisoners should be housed in prisons.

Whilst it is important that people in prison with a mental health problem receive proper treatment and care, it is also important that proper safeguards are in place to ensure to people who are imprisoned are being kept separate from the general population of persons who might be at Glenside Hospital. Patients may be in a secure facility at that hospital for any number of reasons -- and it might not be in the best interests of the community for them to be housed together with prisoners.

Here is a link to the article at AdelaideNow, but the content of this article has already changed a couple of times today, so by the time you read it, it may be very different from the article that I read.

Plea bargaining

With the recent publicity about the delays in criminal trials in the District Court, perhaps it is time for us to look at a formal system of plea bargaining.

For a general explanation of exactly what plea bargaining involves, see this article.

Whilst we do have a system of negotiation here in South Australia, this is not done with the direct assistance of the Judges.

The other main difference is that the DPP and Defence Lawyers cannot "agree" a specific sentence that is then rubber-stamped by a Judge. That of course runs a little contrary to our strongly held principals of judicial independence, and that is one of the arguments against such a system.

The one thing that an accused person often craves is certainty. The uncertainty of the sentence that might ultimately be imposed under the current system is a dis-incentive to some accused people pleading guilty to certain offences.

My clients will frequently say things like, "If you can guarantee I'll get 4 years, then I'll plead guilty," but in our current system such a guarantee is not possible.

Even the usually conservative English legal profession has been examining the possible benefits. See this article.

Plea bargaining: not perfect, but it works - Times Online

British judges, lawyers and prosecutors have spent two years hammering out the finer details of how to introduce a similar system here.

It would not be the solution to all of our problems, but it just might help.